Please use the Search bar to access the archives instead of the Alphabetical / Chronological Archives as we are experiencing technical difficulties with those areas of the website. Thank you.

back to blog home | about Rabbi Buchwald |  back to main NJOP site

Noah 5762-2001

“The ‘Myth’ of the Great Flood”

by Rabbi Ephraim Z. Buchwald

Parashat Noah, the story of the flood, is a truly intriguing Torah portion. Secular scholars speak of the story of the flood as if it were a myth, or a fairy tale.

Not surprisingly, several ancient documents report striking parallels to the story of the flood. Perhaps the most famous document is the Babylonian “Epic of Gilgamish” which tells the story of a man by the name of Utnapishtim. The “gods” decide to destroy the earth, there is a great flood, and because Utnapishtim is the favorite of Eau, one of the gods, he is saved.

Despite the parallels between the “Epic of Gilgamish” and the Torah’s story of Noah, they are in fact strikingly different. In the Babylonian story, the gods arbitrarily decide to destroy the earth as if it were a plaything. Furthermore, the gods choose to save Utnapishtim only because he’s a “favorite” of theirs, not because he is worthy of being saved.

In effect, the Torah revolutionizes the flood story by introducing what is most significant–-the moral element. The world is flooded not because G-d arbitrarily decides to destroy the world, but because the world had become corrupt and destructive. Noah is not arbitrarily saved. He is rescued only because he is deserving. He is, after all, referred to by the Torah, Genesis 6:9, as an “Ish tzadik” and “tamim,” he is a righteous person who was perfect in his generation. In fact, it says of Noah, “et Ha’Elokim hit’halech Noach” that he walked with G-d.

According to tradition, Noah not only builds an ark, but when people pass by and ask Noah what he is doing, he tells them that the world is going to be flooded because of their evil ways. The Midrash Tanchuma 58 relates that in order to give the people an opportunity to repent, the building of the ark continues for 120 years. Finally, Noah enters the ark with his wife, 3 sons, and their wives. Once they’re in the ark, G-d waits an additional 7 days before bringing the flood, again to give the people an opportunity to repent. And even when it begins to rain, the Torah (Genesis 7:12) tells us, “Vay’hee Ha’geshem al ha’aretz,” implying that the rain started to fall lightly. Even at this point, G-d would have reversed his decision and stopped the flood, had the people only repented, but, alas, they did not.

It rains for 40 days and 40 nights. Noah and his family are charged with the unenviable task of caring for all the animals on the ark, not only for 40 days and nights, but, in fact, for a full year, until the earth is sufficiently dry.

The Torah describes an unusual reaction on Noah’s part at the end of that year. After caring for all the animals, a full year of feeding and cleaning, G-d says (Genesis 8:15-16) “Tzay min hatevah,” Noah, get out of the ark, you and your wife, and your sons and your daughter’s-in-law! Can you imagine, after being trapped in the ark, in this stench-ridden vessel, for a full year, G-d has to command Noah, “Tzay min hatevah,” Get out of the ark!? A normal person would have been jumping out of his skin to get out of the ark, but Noah is hesitant to leave.

Eli Weisel, the great writer/philosopher, offers a poignant insight. Weisel calls Noah the first “survivor.” The world had in effect experienced a Holocaust, and Noah is reluctant to walk out of the ark because he knows that the entire world is one giant graveyard, the final resting place of all the people he had known. Noah knows that if he left the ark, he would be walking on the graves of his neighbors and friends–-and he just couldn’t face it.

The story continues. After giving thanks to G-d and bringing sacrifices, the Torah tells us (Genesis 9:20-21), “Va’yachel Noach Ish Ha’Adama Vayitah Kerem,” Noah’s first reaction after the flood is to begin to plant. Planting after a great destruction is surely a meaningful response. It represents hope and belief in the future, but what does Noah plant? He plants a vine. Scripture then informs us, “Vayaisht min hayayin,” Noah drinks the wine of the vineyard, “vayishkar,” he becomes drunk, “vayitgal bitoch ahalo,” and he wallows in the muck in his tent. Poor Noah couldn’t face the fact that everybody except himself and his immediate family had been destroyed in the flood. He needed an escape–-and resorts to alcohol. He’s unable to face reality! He cannot work; he cannot function. He becomes a drunkard.

Noah’s response to the flood is not dissimilar to the reactions of some Holocaust survivors in our own generation. Some survivors were just not capable of facing the fact that they were singled out to live, while their beloved friends and relatives, mothers, fathers, sons, and daughters, had been murdered.

What are the reactions of those who behold Noah in this desperate state? The Torah tells us that Noah had three sons: Shem, Cham, and Yafet. In the biblical text, Cham is always referred to as “Avi Canaan,” the father of Canaan. The Torah tells us (Genesis 9:22) that when Noah was drunk and inebriated, Cham, Avi Canaan, the father of Canaan, “saw his nakedness” and told his two brothers outside. The Rabbis say that the biblical expression “to see a person’s nakedness” often has sexual connotations. In fact, they say that Cham did not just see his father’s nakedness, and mock his father, but that he actually sodomized or castrated his father, and he went and told his brothers. Cham says to his siblings, “Our father is a drunk. This survivor can’t face reality, he’s become a vegetable, he’s a worthless drunk!”

But the two remaining sons of Noah, Shem and Yafet, take a cloak, put it on their own backs, and while walking backwards so they could not see their father, cover their father’s nakedness.

The Bible then tells us (Genesis 9:25-26) that when Noah awoke from his stupor, from his inebriation, “Vayeda et asher asa lo b’no hakatan,” he knew what his youngest son, Cham, had done to him. Noah cries out: “Aroor Canaan,” May Canaan be cursed. Oddly enough, Noah doesn’t curse his son, Cham, he curses his grandson, Cham’s son, Canaan. “Eved avadim yehiyeh l’echav,” May he always be enslaved to his brothers.

Very intriguing. Why does Noah curse his grandson and not his son? Perhaps it is because, of all the children, Cham was the only one who was himself already a father. Cham should have been aware of how difficult it is to be a parent. Of all the children, Cham should have been most sensitive to Noah’s plight. Yet he was the least sensitive! And Noah says, if that’s the way you behave, if that’s the model you provide your children, if you respond to a person in need by acting callously and insensitively, the end result will inevitably be that your own child, Canaan, will be a slave. Just like you, he will be unable to control himself. He’ll be a slave to his own passions and needs, just as you are yourself.

The story of the flood is not at all a myth. It is a narrative replete with endless and fascinating insights, as is the entire Torah. All we need do is study and review it, and in it we shall find profound insights into all human life and human relations.

May you be blessed.